Do I need a solicitor or an advocate?

Do I need a solicitor or an Advocate?

Solicitors are usually your first point of contact for any legal matter. They handle the day-to-day work of a case: taking instructions, gathering evidence, correspondence, negotiation, conveyancing, drafting wills, and general legal advice. Solicitors can represent clients in the lower courts, such as the Sheriff Court.

If you don't already have a solicitor, the Law Society of Scotland's Find a Solicitor tool is a good place to start.

Advocates are specialist courtroom lawyers and legal advisers. They are members of the Faculty of Advocates and have rights of audience in every court in Scotland, including the Court of Session and the High Court of Justiciary. Advocates are typically brought in for:

  • Representation in the higher courts

  • Specialist opinion on complex or high-value legal questions

  • Independent, expert advice at a key stage of a case

  • Tribunal and inquiry work requiring advocacy skills

How the two work together

In most cases, a solicitor will instruct an advocate on a client's behalf once a matter needs specialist courtroom representation or an expert opinion. The solicitor continues to manage the case, while the advocate focuses on the advocacy or the specialist legal question.

Can I instruct an Advocate directly?

Generally, no. Advocates are traditionally instructed by a solicitor on your behalf, and most Advocates cannot take instructions directly from a member of the public or a business.

There are some limited exceptions to this under the Faculty's Direct Access scheme, which allows certain advocates to be instructed directly in specific circumstances.

In short

  • Need general legal help, advice, or paperwork? Start with a solicitor.

  • Need specialist advocacy, a second opinion, or representation in the higher courts? You may need an advocate, usually instructed via your solicitor.

Sources of support

Clerking services

Advocates who subscribe to all of FSL’s services will belong to a stable which is served by an Advocates’ Clerk and Deputy Clerks. Each stable has its own website.

Free Legal Services Unit

As part of a commitment to promote access to justice, the Faculty can arrange for advice and representation to be provided by advocates free of charge.

This pro bono service has been a feature of the Faculty down the centuries and is now provided by volunteer Advocates through the Faculty’s Free Legal Services Unit.  It should be understood from the outset, however, that not all requests for assistance can be met by the Unit - criteria must be met before a case is accepted.

Faculty Dispute Resolution Service

The Faculty Dispute Resolution Service offers a convenient way of securing the services of Advocates as decision makers and neutral dispute resolvers, whether as adjudicators, arbitrators, mediators or other third-party neutrals.

Faculty Appeals Unit

The Faculty Appeals Unit offers support to instructing agents and counsel with all aspects of criminal appeal work, providing advice and information, instructing counsel, ensuring all deadlines and procedural requirements are met, and attending appeal hearings.

Direct Access

Advocates may accept instructions (except in relation to court proceedings) directly from a variety of professionals, public authorities and other individuals and bodies.