Quality Assurance Scheme

The Faculty’s Quality Assurance (QA) Programme helps to maintain these standards by assessing advocacy skills and providing reassurance to the public, the courts and the legal profession.

Quality Assurance Scheme

The Faculty of Advocates is the independent professional body for advocates in Scotland. It regulates professional practice, conduct and discipline, and supports the highest standards of advocacy. The Faculty’s Quality Assurance (QA) Programme helps to maintain these standards by assessing advocacy skills and providing reassurance to the public, the courts and the legal profession, that excellent and continuing advocacy skills are of fundamental importance to the Faculty.

Introduced in 2016, the QA Programme requires Members to demonstrate effective advocacy through a structured oral submission (for example, a short debate or an application made to a court). By effective advocacy what is meant is the standard to be expected of the reasonably competent newly admitted Advocate. It is assessed by reference to the assessment criteria for each key skill set out below.

Assessments focus on how well the advocate assists the court in deciding the issue before it. Performance is assessed against established criteria, including case analysis, structure, use of language, engagement with the decision-maker, use of legal authorities, and presentation and use of documents. Assessments are carried out by a QA Assessor, who is a senior Member of Faculty, who has undertaken training by the Director of Training & Education.

The programme is overseen by a Quality Assurance Director, who is nominated by the Dean of Faculty. The current QA Director is Astrid Smart, K.C. and she is assisted in running the diet by the Deans Secretariat and the Director of Training & Education.

The QA Programme runs annually with the diet taking place in November and December and runs over a five-year rolling cycle. Each year, around one-fifth of the practising membership is required to complete an assessment and meet the standard of effective advocacy. Each Member can select an exercise of either a Civil or a Criminal exercise.

Please click here to view a copy of the QA Programme Regulations.

Annual QA Statements

After each QA diet, the Faculty publishes its annual quality assurance statement which includes details of the number of members assessed each year. You can read copies of the statements below.

Annual QA Statement 2022
File type
PDF,
File size
116.39kB
Annual QA Statement 2023
File type
PDF,
File size
252.56kB
Annual QA Statement 2024
File type
PDF,
File size
232.47kB
Annual QA Statement 2025
File type
PDF,
File size
220.2kB